The Danville Series by Cadillac Red Disclaimer: The characters of Fox Mulder, Dana Scully, Walter Skinner, et al do not belong to me; they belong to Chris Carter and Fox. I mean no harm and will make no money from their use. Spoilers: None Setting: Somewhere in the middle of the fourth season. Rating: PG. Some discipline, no slash. Title: Too Good To Be True Author: Cadillac Red Summary: The evidence would indicate that Mulder has been a model FBI agent, since Skinner helped him start "Facing Consequences." But not everything is as it seems . . . Too Good To Be True Crystal City, Virginia Walter Skinner strode out of the modern high-rise he called home and headed for the parking lot to begin his morning commute. He walked purposefully, as always, but his gait had an unusual ease and he whistled softly to himself. It was a beautiful Spring morning, he had no appointments before 11, and, anyway, it was just barely 6:30 a.m. Very few others would even be in the office for another hour after he arrived. Enough time for a cup of coffee and a unhurried review of the quarterly reports. He knew they would look good. Skinner's agents were always near the top of effectiveness and solve rate reports, although his budget results were usually blown out of the water by some outlandish X-file case, and he normally tried not to even think about the "missing reports" list that traditionally had Fox Mulder's name printed right on the form. (Another Assistant Director's idea of a joke -- one that never made Skinner even crack a smile.) But things had changed and even the budget and closed case paperwork report from his departments were unbelievably good. At the end of the last quarter things had begun an upturn; this quarter, he knew the numbers would put him and his agents at the top of the Bureau's highly competitive results. Skinner actually chuckled out loud considering the unlikely turn of events that sparked his uncharacteristically lighthearted mood. Some 20 minutes later he steered his car past the security guard and headed down the ramp into the FBI's underground parking garage. Skinner had always like his job; he knew it was important, necessary work. But lately, he found himself actually enjoying it. Fox Mulder, former "Bad Boy of the FBI" was behaving himself and all was right with Assistant Director Walter S. Skinner's world. Yet, that's exactly what had finally happened, and for the past four months, Fox Mulder had been practically angelic. Cases solved (whether they were generated in or out of the X-files division!), reports on time, budgets adhered to. At the Management Conference last month, Skinner had been cited by the Deputy Director for having gotten "the Mulder kid" back on track. After years of putting up with remarks from the other AD's about his "problem child," it was gratifying at the least. But more satisfying for Skinner was the fact that Mulder really seemed to have turned himself, and his career, around. The truth was, the fact that he'd stopped taking unnecessary risks and running off half-cocked at the mention of a "UFO " or "Bigfoot sighting" was the real victory in Skinner's mind. He bounded up the stairs toward the lobby level, still reveling in the feeling of accomplishment he momentarily allowed himself. Mulder had not only put his nose to the proverbial grindstone, he'd distinguished himself on several FBI and inter-agency efforts in the past months, even being requested as ASAC on a case several weeks before that involved nothing more paranormal than a would-be televangelist who Mulder quickly brought down on mail fraud charges. It was almost too good to be true, Skinner smiled to himself. Entering the lobby from the garage entrance, he was startled to see the subject of his mental reverie exiting the FBI building through the Employee's entrance directly across from him. Skinner glanced at his watch; it was almost 7 a.m., but this was an unusual time for one of his agents to be in, let alone an agent who was decidedly between cases. And it was a very odd time for anyone to be LEAVING the building. Skinner couldn't help it, he shifted immediately into investigative mode, checking the off hours sign in log as soon as he cleared the security check-point. Agent Mulder had signed in at 6:15 and out again at 6:50. He had a niggling feeling about this but he brushed it aside. Mulder had been so well-behaved of late, Skinner reasoned, he had certainly earned a little trust. He tucked the entire episode in the back of his mind and headed for his office. A few minutes before 9 a.m., Kimberly stuck her head in his office to say "good morning" and he leaned back in his chair as she entered the office to go over his schedule. He had been right about the reports; the departments he led topped the results list for the last quarter. He gave Kim an uncharacteristic smile and asked her to call Mulder and Scully to come up to his office. Their results were outstanding and had driven the rest of the teams to the top. He wanted to commend them both. "I can get Agent Scully," Kim said. "But Agent Mulder called in a sick day today. . . . Or do you want me to call him at home?" At this news, the niggling in the back of Skinner's head became a jackhammer. Externally, though, he was the picture of composure. All he said was, "No need, Kim. I'll just speak with Agent Scully." He sat back and waited for her to respond to Kim's summons. Special Agent Dana Scully entered Assistant Director Skinner's office some minutes later. He was finishing up a phone call but Skinner motioned for her to sit. She looked calm and unconcerned, the very picture of a successful professional woman. He studied her relaxed posture out of the corner of his eye as he replaced the phone and turned to address her. "Thank you for coming so quickly, Agent Scully," he said. "Is everything all right, sir?" she queried immediately. "I was about to leave for Quantico but Kim said you needed to see me first. You remember that I'm filling in for Jane Kelley this week?" Skinner immediately recalled that Scully was covering the last week of the forensics rotation at the FBI academy for a colleague who left early on maternity leave the week before. Scully had been requested on an emergency basis by the AD in charge of Quantico. Skinner had been impressed by the fact that Mulder didn't even make a face when informed them she was needed to finish out the class schedule. "How is Agent Kelley's baby," he asked calmly. "Oh, fine, I think. After classes end today, I'm planning to go see her and the baby, I'm staying down in Quantico for the rest of the week," she replied, then focused her attention on the issue at hand. "What was it you wanted to see me about, sir?" "I just had a look at the quarterlies, Agent Scully and our results are at the top of all of them," he replied, leaning forward over his desk. "Your work, and Agent Mulder's, has been outstanding and I wanted to tell you both it hasn't gone unnoticed. But I understand he's out ill today." Dana Scully glowed and she quickly replied that she wished her partner was here to share the praise. "He's been unbelievable the past few months, sir. Like another person . . . . I wondered about it at first but . . . . it just seems like he's turned over a new leaf or something. And people are getting to see how good he really is." She blushed a little now, at the personal nature of her response but Skinner could see she was immensely proud of her partner. "Yes," he replied. "Almost too good to be true. Perhaps I'll give him a call and share the good news with him." He was probing for her reaction. "I'm sure that'd make him feel a lot better," she said. She looked at her watch and suddenly realized she had to make a move or she'd be late for her class. "He left me a voice message this morning that he ate something bad and had been sick all night. He said he was turning off his phone and going to sleep. That was around 6:45, according to the time on the voice-mail. But I'm sure he'll check in when he wakes up." Skinner had watched Scully carefully throughout this recitation and he was certain that she was telling it to him the way she knew it. Scully was not an especially good liar, he thought. Not like that partner of hers. Skinner knew in his gut that a check of the phone logs would show that call to Scully's voice-mail had been dialed from the basement office. He didn't want to jump to any conclusions but. . . . things were not looking good for Agent Mulder at the moment. After Scully left, Skinner reviewed a number of reports and then took his 11 o'clock meeting with another pair of agents. After that, he had a scheduled lunch with the Section Chief. More praise about the quarterly results and, of course, the amazing turnaround Special Agent Mulder had made. Skinner thought his sandwich tasted like straw and he felt like a fraud listening to the Chief verbally pat him on the back, knowing something was just not as it seemed. He begged off as early as he could and headed down to the basement to have a look around Mulder's office. There must be some clue as to what Mulder had been doing there that morning. He had tried to call the missing agent several times but, as Scully thought, his phone was turned off. Mulder's desk was the same jumble it always was but now Skinner recognized that it was systemized chaos -- everything in a pile and every pile in its place. The younger agent's mind was the same mass of information stored every which way but, as with the piles, he could always find what he needed. It was an amazing thing to watch him work, Skinner thought. But now he was trying to re-enact what Mulder had done that morning and he found, unfortunately, that his own mind didn't work the same way. He was stumped. He had just given up and was leaving when he noticed a single sheet of paper in the wastebasket next to the fax machine. The cleaning crew would have been in at the end of the day yesterday so the fax had been received since then. He leaned over and retrieved it, noting that it was something that had not printed correctly the first time; the image was half off the page. But he could clearly make out a logo that said "Lone Gunmen" and a handwritten note to Mulder that read: "not something you'll be able to investigate "officially." Get away from the suits and---" That was all there was but it was enough to give Skinner the beginning of a Mulder size headache. It had been months since he'd had one, but he recognized it right away. With a little research he was able to ascertain that the "Lone Gunmen" were three wacko's who published a newsletter that was a mixture of anti-government ravings and paranoid interpretations of everything from satellite television to fluoridated water and Sure enough, Mulder's car was parked down the street. Skinner paid off the taxi and entered the building. There was no listing for the "Lone Gunmen," He decided to do a floor by floor canvass and, on the third floor, it paid off. An open door down the hallway and voices, one of them definitely Mulder's. "Get in here, Frohike," Mulder badgered someone, "and close the door. I'm not supposed to be here, you know. I called in sick this morning." A little elf of a man was standing in the hall, his back to Skinner. He was attempting to push a large box into the room from which Mulder's voice had come. "This would be a whole lot easier if someone helped me," he whined. "Oh come on, Melvin," Mulder said impatiently, emerging from the room to help this "Frohike" with the box. "Let's get it in here NOW! I can't take a chance on being seen. Bureau policy says, if you call in sick, you have to stay home unless you go to see your doctor. And sometimes they check up on you. Not that I think that'll happen, given my recent performance, but if someone did-- well, you don't know the shit I'd get." "That's what we like about you, Mulder," another voice called from inside the room. "Your ego's untouchable, and your level of paranoia's even higher than ours!" "Very funny, Langly," Mulder retorted, moving behind the box to give it a final shove. Skinner took a position just down the hall, leaning against the wall, his arms crossed over his chest. Mulder continued his monologue. "I'm not saying it'll happen. Let's just say I'm--" ". . . . busted." Mulder's voice dropped precipitously and in a heartbeat, he had turned sheet white. He reflexively stood straight up, dropping his side of the box, causing Frohike to topple over. "You're looking well, Agent Mulder," Skinner said cheerily. "You must have made a miraculous recovery." He turned to the elf who was looking up over the box from his position on the floor, then nodded to the two heads that stuck themselves out of the doorway. "These must be your physicians," he continued pleasantly. "Dr's Moe, Larry and Curly, I presume." The ride back from Maryland was a study in tension. Mulder drove, as carefully as he knew how. He stopped at every light before it turned red, and even used his blinkers to signal lane changes, something he hadn't actually done since passing his road test back in high school! He tried desperately to come up with a non-controversial topic to break the silence but failed miserably. He finally sank into resigned silence and waited for the storm. Skinner finally broke the spell. "Turn here," he said, indicating that Mulder should exit onto Jefferson Davis Highway. Mulder clung desperately to the hope that Skinner just wanted to be dropped off. Taking the break in silence as a GOOD sign, Mulder decided to go on the offensive. "I'd just like to say, sir. . . . I mean I'd like to point out—not that you need my help remembering this . . . .," he stammered. Skinner's eyebrows shot up to the top of his head but Mulder had his eyes on the road and didn't pick up the non-verbal cue. He started again. "I mean, I just want to remind you that, well, this is the FIRST time in four months that I . . . ." He turned his head briefly to see whether there was a response from the Assistant Director and looked into what could only be described as "cold fury." Mulder shut right up and turned 100% of his attention back to the road before him. He was busy memorizing the license plates of every other car on the street when Skinner finally spoke. "What that tells me, Agent Mulder," he said evenly, "is that you actually DO know the difference between what you do and what you SHOULD do. The past four months are proof that you CAN follow the rules when you have to. Hell, if you put your mind to it, Mulder, you could be the FBI's poster child for model behavior. . . . We could put you on the recruiting posters!" The stress level in Skinner's voice escalated with each word and Mulder intuitively understood that no response would help his cause. He held his tongue, and swallowed hard. He willed himself not to press his foot harder on the gas pedal. No matter how bad he wanted this trip to be over, speeding would not help, he reasoned. In another minute they were pulling up beside Skinner's high-rise and Mulder steered the car into the "No Standing" zone outside the front door. Skinner sighed deeply and pulled on the door handle. He tried valiantly not to let his relief show as Skinner opened the door and swung his long legs out of the car. From a standing position, he put his hand on the door to close it then leaned down to say good night, Mulder imagined. "Park the car and come up, Agent Mulder," he said. Skinner slammed the door hard. Fox Mulder's head immediately dropped to the steering wheel. He was uncertain how long he had stayed there when a loud HONK! HONK! from behind him startled him back to reality. In his rear view mirror he saw a blue-haired old lady smiling and waving for him to move his car. He didn't know how much time he'd lost – a sensation not unfamiliar to Fox Mulder, but always before under decidedly different circumstances. On legs of lead, he entered the building. "Mr. Skinner said to send you right up," the smiling doorman greeted him. Mulder nodded and headed to the elevator. It was waiting open. Mulder hit "16" and began the ascent to hell. The young man muttered to himself and raged internally as the elevator sped upward. He had worked himself into a frenzy by the time the elevator reached the 16th floor. The door slid open and Mulder looked toward Skinner's closed door. He decided to refuse to participate and angrily hit the "Lobby" button. The doors closed quietly and he began the ride down. Second thoughts immediately welled within him. The fact was, the past four months had been kind of nice in a lot of ways. Mulder actually found he enjoyed not being at the epicenter of trouble all the time and even started to appreciate being included in some of the Bureau's more mainstream activities. And he really liked the look of pride that occasionally passed over the AD's face, and Scully's too, when he was impressing the hell out of the "suits." The doors silently opened on the lobby and the doorman looked inside quizzically, at the young man quietly pounding his head on the elevator wall. After another moment's hesitation, he resignedly slammed his hand on the number "16" and the doors closed once again. About a minute later, Mulder knocked hesitantly on Walter Skinner's front door. It was unlocked and cracked open at his touch; Mulder stepped nervously inside to find Assistant Director Skinner sitting in his living room, staring at the doorway. Mulder closed the door behind him and walked into the lion's den. "Twenty-seven minutes, Mulder," Skinner growled. "Where did you park? Pittsburgh?" Mulder thought the sarcasm was uncalled for, but he wisely decided not to mention it. Instead he focused his sight on Skinner sitting in the brown, leather chair he remembered so well from the last time he'd been here. The AD had changed into sweat pants and a gray tee-shirt that made it impossible to miss the massive, muscled arms that turned Mulder's blood cold on sight. He fought off a wave of fear. "Okay, we don't need to talk about why you're here, do we Mulder? I would think that's clear even to you at this point. You've made some bad choices today, Agent Mulder, and now it's time to face the consequences of those errors in judgment." Mulder was finding it hard to make eye contact with Skinner and he fixed his attention on a spot about six inches to the left of Skinner's head. "My belt is on the bed inside, Agent Mulder. Go get it," Skinner said evenly. His legs stayed rooted in their spot and he shook his head. First hesitantly, then more forcefully. "Don't make me tell you again, Mulder," Skinner said threateningly. "I'm in no mood for your crap! And you do NOT want to push me right now! GO GET THE BELT!" Mulder hardened his stance, and the set of his jaw. Walter Skinner's head shot up and he looked daggers at the rebellious young agent before him. "What did you say?" he bellowed. But he was in a self-destructive spiral he couldn't seem to pull out of. And what he actually said next was, "I said 'NO.' I'm not getting your belt for you! Go get it yourself!" Walter Skinner called on every shred of self-control he could muster fighting the urge to smash Mulder right in the face. Instead, he stood quietly and walked into the bedroom. Returning, Mulder saw the belt in question doubled over in his right hand and a shiver ran quickly down his spine. Skinner walked up next to him. Speaking quietly, he instructed Mulder to take down his jeans and his shorts. Having defied him already, Mulder thought better of taking it any further and he unbuttoned, unzipped and pushed down the clothing in question. Skinner's left arm went behind Mulder's back and he was quickly bent over under Skinner's massive arm. Without delay, he felt the belt come down hard on his bare backside. Skinner made no sound, and neither did Mulder except for the occasional reluctant gasp. After ten strokes, Skinner stopped and let him up. Skinner headed for the bedroom, then immediately returned without the belt. He sat back down in the overstuffed leather chair. Mulder started to pull up his pants, sighing with relief that the whole thing was over. "Don't do that," Skinner said quietly. "Let's try this again now. Go get the belt, Agent Mulder." "Wh- Wh-Why?" he stammered. "You just p- punished me!" "That was for disobeying my direct order just now. Don't mistake my leniency over that issue for a reprieve, Mulder," he said. "Go get the belt." His stubborn streak of self-destructiveness took over again and he firmly shook his head. "No," he said. "I'm not telling you again, Agent Mulder. You know what to do." "No!" Skinner stood and made the trip to the bedroom, again. Mulder closed his eyes, trying to will this all to be a bad dream. He was startled back to reality by a strong arm pushing on his back, bending him over once more. CRAACKK! The belt came down on his already striped bottom. "Oww!," he gasped, unable to contain his reaction any longer. Tears welled up in his eyes but he firmly pressed his lips together, willing the tears back from whence they came. The belt came down, again and again, fifteen more strokes in all. Mulder's backside was a deep, burning red now and he would have been squirming mightily were he not held firmly in Skinner's iron grasp. It ended as quietly as it began. Skinner made the trek into his bedroom and returned empty-handed to the brown leather chair. He watched Mulder for a moment. The young agent was rubbing hard at his eyes, angrily brushing aside the tears that were running down his cheeks. This was taking a toll on both of them, and Skinner knew he now understood the meaning of that old cliché his father sometimes used about this "hurting me more than you." "Agent Mulder," he said evenly. "I'm going to tell you one more time and I think it's time you obeyed me. . . . Go get the belt." Mulder swayed a little but didn't quite take a step in the direction of the bedroom. It looked to Skinner like he was unable to make the decision to surrender his position in this battle of wills. Skinner recognized the critical juncture they had reached. If he couldn't break this willful, mistrustful streak, he was afraid there was no hope for this brilliant, troubled young man. He stood up. "No!" Mulder cried. "I was gonna go, I . . . I was just gonna go," he said tearfully, taking a hesitant step toward the bedroom. Walter Skinner took another step toward Mulder, who was now sobbing pitifully, his head hanging down. Skinner took Mulder's chin in his large hand and lifted his head until his eyes met the Assistant Director's head on. "That's a good choice, Agent Mulder," was all he said, but relief flooded the tear-filled hazel eyes before him. "I'll wait here." Mulder hobbled into the bedroom and found the leather belt that Skinner had violently thrown on the bed a few moments earlier. He picked it up, swallowing hard, and headed back to the living room. Without lifting his head, he handed the strip of leather to the Assistant Director. Sighing, he felt a momentary rush of relief come over him. A similar thought was going through Skinner's head. But he hardened his resolve to get through the next part. Mulder had broken more rules today than most Agents manage to break in their entire careers. Overriding every instinct pushing him toward leniency, he gave Mulder another moment to collect himself before proceeding. "All right, you remember the drill," Skinner said, taking the younger man by the arm and pushing him toward the back of the chair. "What are you doing," Mulder asked fearfully. "Haven't I been punished enough already?" "That was for your defiance here tonight, Agent Mulder. Now we're finally getting to the punishment you bought yourself with that stunt you pulled today," he said. He tried to get Mulder over the chair back, but the young man stopped cold in his tracks. Skinner knew he could muscle him into position, but he decided to give Mulder his head, and see what happened next. "I . . . I . . . can't . . . , " he whispered. "Please, no more. . ." He looked beseechingly at the AD "I know I deserve it but . . . ." Skinner watched him conduct some inner dialogue with himself; a fierce struggle played out in his eyes, and on his face. Unspoken communication occurred between the two of them, Skinner thought, although he had to admit he didn't quite understand how that worked. Mulder closed his eyes momentarily, and took a deep, calming breath. When he opened his eyes, he looked at the AD and nodded, as though answering a question Skinner had not posed. Then he walked to the back of the chair and bent forward over it. Walter Skinner was nearly choked with emotion; such a simple act of trust, and faith in his judgment was something he didn't expect to see from this troubled young man on this occasion. Skinner reached down and ruffled the hair on the back of Mulder's head. "It'll all be over in a few minutes, Fox," he said gently. Taking a deep breath himself, he raised his voice to normal volume. "What is this punishment for, Agent Mulder?" he asked. Hard as it was this time, he wanted Mulder to know that they would stick with the ritual they had established the first time Skinner took a belt to him. The Skinner family tradition would be upheld and Mulder would have no doubt what had earned him this strapping. "For calling in a sick day when I wasn't sick," Mulder said firmly, as the strap came down on his already burning buttocks. "AAAhhh!" Another lick. "And for lying to you—owwww!" Choking sobs came quickly, followed by a hiccup. Skinner paused for a second to let him catch his breath. Then he continued because he wanted to get this over with almost as bad as Mulder did. CRRAACCCK! "What else, Mulder?" "For lying to Scully," he said tearfully, trying to remember the rest of it. The day seemed so long ago now, he was having trouble recalling all the details. "And what else, Agent Mulder?" Skinner asked, bringing the belt down yet again. "For lying to Kim!" Skinner was brought up short by this one and he nearly missed his target with the belt. A small smile passed briefly over his face. It was clear Mulder was having trouble concentrating on the litany of his sins. "That's roughly the same as lying to me, Agent Mulder," he said dryly. "Let's not forget sharing confidential Bureau documents with civilians." The strap smacked loudly on the young agent's blistered backside and he let out a convulsive sob. "And leaving your apartment on a sick day. But of course, that's related to not really being sick on a sick day, isn't it?" Skinner had lost the heart to continue. With his left arm, he grasped Mulder's shoulder, then rubbed his upper back until his sobbing began to subside. Mulder made no attempt to get up, still weeping inconsolably. Finally Skinner forced the issue. "We're done now, Mulder," he said, pulling him to his feet. The young man stood and immediately buried his face in Skinner's right shoulder, still sobbing. Walter Skinner wrapped an arm around him and let him cry it out. As his tears finally dried, Mulder suddenly looked up at Assistant Director Skinner, looking for all the world like a hanged man who just remembered he was about to be shot, too. "There's just one more thing, sir," he said. "When I told you today that this was the first time I went AWOL in the past four months?" Mulder was having trouble making eye contact again and Skinner held his breath waiting for this shoe to drop. Mulder closed his eyes and rushed on. "When I told you that, sir, well, that was a lie." He opened his eyes and blurted out the rest. "Last month, when you were at the Management Conference and Scully was visiting her brother-- Skinner stopped him before he could give any more details. The AD's blood pressure was just settling down and he was certain Mulder would say something to send it shooting back up. "I think we'll bank that little incident for now, Agent Mulder," he said. "If we never need to do this again, well then you've got a pass on it. But if we do, I promise you, it'll cost you -- with interest applied! And I'll expect you to remind me about it. Deal?" To his great relief, Fox Mulder gave him an exhausted smile, then his eyelids fluttered and almost closed. The Assistant Director could see he was nearly asleep on his feet. Skinner first attempted to put his clothes back in place, but just getting his boxers up set off a wave of shudders. Walter Skinner had only pushed his own father once the way Mulder pushed Skinner tonight -- with nearly identical results. "I know, I know it hurts, Mulder," he said gently. He led the chastened agent to the couch and helped him lie down on his stomach. He grabbed a throw pillow and put it under Mulder's head, then removed his shoes and jeans. Finally, he pulled a blanket out of a trunk next to the sofa and covered the now sleeping form. He looked down at his best, and most troublesome, agent and was struck by how young he looked in sleep. Skinner reached down and brushed a stray lock of hair off his forehead and Mulder murmured something unintelligible and snuggled down further under the blanket. An hour later Walter Skinner sat once again in the overstuffed brown leather chair, the TV on very low. He had an open box of lo mein in one hand and chopsticks in the other and was making short order of the dinner "The Peking Palace" had delivered a few minutes earlier. He'd ordered enough for two, but it now appeared Mulder was down for the night. It was just as well, Skinner admitted. He doubted the young agent could sit long enough to eat, or drive himself home, and it was a hell of a long walk to Alexandria. His phone rang and he reached for it quickly, not wanting it to disturb the rest that had been hard earned by Mulder earlier in the evening. "Sir?" Agent Dana Scully began. "I'm sorry to disturb you, but I haven't been able to reach Mulder all day. Do you know if he's on assignment somewhere?" "Yes, actually, he is currently "under cover," Agent Scully," Walter Skinner said, glancing at the prone form in deep, dreamless sleep on his couch. "Nothing to worry about, though, I think he'll be back in the saddle by the time you return from Quantico on Monday." "All right, sir. As long as he's okay. I guess it's just an old habit, checking up on him. I know I don't need to anymore. He's been so good lately, it's just hard to get used to!" she smiled over the phone. "Yes, too good to be true actually," Skinner told her. "But we're working on that. Good night, Agent Scully!" THE END